Grilled Oysters with Fish Monger Butter and Parmesan
As the song goes, “do you know what it means to miss New Orleans?” If you do, make these buttery, cheesy grilled oysters, crack open a beer, and you’re almost there. Icy platters of raw oysters on the half shell are a French Quarter staple of course. But, are you acquainted with the claim to fame of Drago’s Seafood Restaurant– broiled oysters, topped with a garlicky butter, Parmesan and bread crumbs?
The trick, here, is seasoning the oysters with a compound butter (this one loaded with garlic, green onions, and parsley), topping with a pinch of Parm and grilling over a medium fire until the oysters are just cooked. The oysters cook quickly and are best slurped from the shell (when they’re warm enough to handle), which makes them the perfect “gather ‘round the grill” appetizer for a backyard barbecue.
Grilled Oysters with Fish Monger Butter and Parmesan
A bit of planning makes these oysters easier to knock out on the fly. Make the compound a day or up to a week in advance. Note that you’ll want the butter at room temp–not melted–to blend with the other ingredients.) You can dress the shucked oysters and refrigerate them a couple hours before you plan to grill. Use tongs (or your hands depending on your fire) to move them around the heat as needed.
Ingredients
1 stick unsalted butter, softened to room temperature
The night (or morning) before grilling, use a rubber spatula to combine the softened butter with the Fish Monger, scallions, parsley, worcestershire sauce and hot sauce. Transfer the butter mixture to a sheet of plastic wrap. Use the wrap to shape the mixture into a log about 1 ½ inches in diameter. Seal the ends and refrigerate for at least 3 hours (or up to a week in advance).
Top each oyster with a teaspoon or so of the cold compound butter and 1 tablespoon of the grated Parmesan. You can then refrigerate the dressed oysters for up to a few hours, until ready to grill.
Build a hot, even fire in the PK. Open all the air vents fully. Place the oysters between grill grates, keeping them as level as you can. Close the lid and cook for about 3 minutes before checking. The oysters should be gently bubbling and just starting to curl at the edges. Remove the oysters carefully with tongs and serve immediately with vinegary hot sauce on the side.
Recipe Note
You won’t need all of the compound butter for this recipe. Use leftovers to top grilled fish, toss with pasta or to cook eggs.